Lewis Mumford on the city
These short film clips featuring Lewis Mumford, author of the City in History, were recently published on the Planum website.
Before the end of 1961 the New York publishing company Harcourt, Brace and Co. had the first edition of Lewis Mumford’s highly successful book The City In History ready for publication. Two years later, in 1963, the National Film Board of Canada funded the production of six documentaries, each lasting 27 minutes, for a series entitled Mumford On The City. The material for the films, based on the book, was prepared by Mumford himself. The director Ian MacNeill wrote the film script and produced the various parts: The City: Heaven and Hell, The City: Cars Or People, The City And Its Region, The Heart of the city, The City As Man’s Home and The City and the Future. In 1963 Mumford was 68 years old and agreed to appear as the presenter of the six films, expressing his personal view about the future of the western city, interspersed with pictures of places, cities, archaeological documents, works of art and architecture.
The City in History remains a classic text of urban design. Mumford urged that technology achieves a balance with nature and hoped for a rediscovery of urban principles that emphasised humanity’s organic relationship to its environment. Forty-five years on, the film clips look incredibly old and the message delivered in a rather morbid and factious manner (to quote Jane Jacobs), with a slightly ‘Outer Limits’ or ‘Twilight Zone’ ambience. Yet some of the key ideas promoted by Mumford have increasing resonance with the sustainability and green agenda of the early 21st century. In the increasingly praxis orientated and commodified world of urban design, whether anyone is listening or not is another matter.
Jul 21st 2008
Hmm, we may have colour film now, but we haven’t moved on much otherwise in the last 45 years, have we… Mumford’s themes - that the the city should exist for people rather than cars, that land should be seen as more than simply a commodity, and the need for a new urban form to reflect the vitality and diversity of our culture - are just a relevant now as they were half a century ago.
In fact, surely they are more relevant now, given that 45 years have passed and we still haven’t turned the corner. I think Mr Mumford would be even more factious now if he could see our lack of wisdom.
Jul 21st 2008
thanks for commenting Nick - the City in History was required reading for me and it still makes it into the top 50 urban design texts though I’m sure that few people bother to read it now. Maybe even fewer after seeing the video. J B Cullingworth next!